So, Her Dress Did It?

Why blaming clothes misses the real problem

5 min read

1 hour ago

Listen

First of all, this is purely my opinion and I’m genuinely open to a healthy, respectful discussion. I’m not supporting any specific gender here. I’m neither a feminist nor a “male supporter.” I’m simply an observer trying to understand the conversation by watching the media, thinking through the arguments, and writing this down.

I’m from Andhra Pradesh. Recently, one of the most heated debates in the Telugu states has been about how women dress. The discussion began after an actor used an inappropriate word and advised women not to wear revealing clothes for their own safety.

What followed was a wave of backlash. People began criticizing him with arguments like:

“Even small children get raped. Even fully covered women aren’t spared. This has nothing to do with clothing. It’s about the male mindset.”

“Men are asking women to be saved from men. What an irony.”

And some men even commented like this:

“Girls are wearing extremely revealing clothes and calling it ‘their choice.’”

The debate kept escalating.

So, what’s actually going on here? Who’s right?

Two Statements, One Conflict

Let’s analyze the two core statements logically.

Statement 1:

“Women shouldn’t wear revealing clothes for their own safety.”

This statement isn’t entirely wrong, but it’s incomplete. Clothing alone doesn’t ensure safety. (NCRB data shows 90%+ rapes aren’t linked to “revealing” attire anyway.)
It’s usually meant as a precaution, not a solution.

Statement 2:

“This is not about clothing; it’s about the mindset of men. Men need to change.”

This is also true, but it does not apply to all men.
Men who commit such crimes absolutely need to be stopped and punished. No argument there.

However, logically, the second statement does not counter the first one.

Saying ‘men should change’ doesn’t cancel the need for precautions. It’s not a counterargument. It’s a continuation of the discussion.

And there’s no irony here. If some people behave badly, we call that behavior bad. That’s all.

The Core Issue: Risk Management

The real issue here is risk management in an unsafe society. Even when something should not happen, people still take precautions.

You lock your door even though stealing is wrong.
You wear a helmet even though accidents aren’t your fault.

And yes, it’s sad.

But the world works by managing reality, not just ideals.

So the question becomes: Is it right or wrong for women to wear whatever they want?

Perspective Shift

If you’re a man, consider this: Imagine you were overweight and worked hard for three years to get fit. Wouldn’t you want to wear a fitted shirt that shows your physique?

Get Surya teja Tumu’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

That’s not arrogance. That’s confidence.

In the same way, if a woman reveals a bit of skin or wears something that makes her feel confident, it follows the same logic.

Confidence, Not Arrogance: Same Logic for Both Genders

Of course, everything has limits. Walking naked in public isn’t acceptable in a shared society for both genders. But women wearing crop tops or such clothes does not justify judgment or harassment.

As humans, we may glance at women. That’s instinctive. But staring and creeping someone out? That’s a choice.

The real question for a mature man is simple:
Are you making her uncomfortable?

That alone defines the line.

The Friction of Change

A major reason many Indian men feel uncomfortable is cultural conditioning. They grew up seeing grandmothers and mothers dressed conservatively, with clothing wrongly linked to character. This mindset doesn’t change overnight.

Western influences aren’t the problem. The issue is that cultural change in India is fast and uneven, and when dressing styles evolve quicker than mindsets, discomfort and friction among men raised with traditional views become inevitable.

Men’s Discomfort: Traditional Eyes Meet Modern Dressing

This transition and adjustment will take time.

Dealing With Harassment

Now, about the men who actually harass women. The uncomfortable truth is,

Awareness campaigns don’t change criminals.

Some men are criminals. Most men are not.

But society often fails to control the criminals.

Good men don’t need lectures.
Bad men don’t listen to lectures.

Real change comes from systems, not slogans.

When Risk (legal punishment) > Reward (harassment) → Behavior changes.

Risk > Reward = Less Crime: Economics’ Simple Rule That Works Everywhere

Stronger laws, faster justice, and visible consequences matter because crime grows when punishment is slow.

When criminals know they will be caught and punished quickly, they become afraid to commit crimes. That fear helps stop wrongdoing.

Alongside this, there is also a long-term fix: teaching boys boundaries early, normalizing consent, and calling out bad behavior within men’s circles. Many parents are already doing this, and that is good.

This works, but gradually.

Final Thoughts

Despite everything, some men will still feel uncomfortable with revealing clothes. That discomfort largely comes from cultural upbringing, not logic. If women are comfortable wearing what they choose, that’s fine.

As for attention-seeking “pseudo-feminism,” that’s a different discussion altogether.

The responsibility lies not with women but with men. Don’t objectify, and don’t make someone uncomfortable by staring.

This applies to both genders, but due to existing power dynamics, women face this far more often than men.

True equality is a world where neither gender suppresses the other.

A world where women move freely without fear, and innocent men are not unfairly blamed.

Feel free to share your thoughts and have an insightful discussion. Together, we can move forward.