Vincent Kompany reportedly prompted a rethink: Bayern Munich got everything right by selling Matthijs de Ligt

Goal | 20.11.2026 12:55

To widespread outrage, Bayern Munich sold Matthijs de Ligt rather than Dayot Upamecano in 2024. Their careers could hardly have diverged more since.

Vincent Kompany took charge of Bayern Munich in the summer of 2024 and, according to widespread reports at the time, immediately pushed for an unpopular decision. It concerned the future of the club's central defence.

Bayern had five centre-backs: Dayot Upamecano, Min-Jae Kim, Matthijs de Ligt, Eric Dier and new signing Hiroki ito. One had to leave. The club's hierarchy reportedly wanted Upamecano to go, but Kompany saw great potential in him, particularly his pace. The new coach reportedly favoured selling de Ligt instead.

The Dutchman eventually joined Manchester United for €45 million. After a nightmare year there, he is now considered a candidate for sale. Upamecano, meanwhile, has become one of the world's best centre-backs at Bayern Munich. The decision that looked so questionable at the time has proved exactly right.

Petition called for Matthijs de Ligt to stay at Bayern Munich

A year after Upamecano's €42.5 million move from RB Leipzig, Julian Nagelsmann wanted another top-class centre-back in 2022. Matthijs de Ligt arrived to widespread surprise, with Bayern paying Juventus Turin a hefty €67 million for the former Ajax Amsterdam wonderkid. The move was hailed as a coup despite the fee: at 22, he was considered one of the world's most promising centre-backs.

De Ligt lived up to expectations. He finished second behind Jamal Musiala in the vote for Bayern player of the year after his first season, and remained the club's most reliable centre-back in his second. His selfless style of play and approachable manner made him a fan favourite. So why sell him instead of the injury-prone, error-prone Upamecano?

To prevent that, Bayern Munich fans launched an online petition entitled "Keep de Ligt! Wir wollen de Ligt!", which said, among other things: "Selling Matthijs de Ligt would be absolutely the wrong decision, and we would certainly regret it enormously. That is why we are using our voice to draw attention to the fact that we must NOT make this mistake!"

An impressive 71,840 people signed the petition. "That touches my heart," de Ligt himself said. But Bayern Munich's hierarchy ignored the fans' wishes and sold de Ligt to Manchester United in mid-August.

Dayot Upamecano extended his contract in early 2026

Kompany then largely paired Upamecano with Kim in central defence. Despite occasional mistakes, the partnership worked very well overall. At Manchester United, de Ligt struggled and soon drew fire from sharp-tongued English television pundits, a fate that has seemingly befallen every United new signing for years.

"It’s not about us feeling vindicated. Matthijs de Ligt was a top centre-back too," board member for sport Max Eberl said in November. "But we had to make a decision somehow. We made it, and it’s working." By the 2025/26 season at the latest, the rethink apparently prompted by Kompany had proved an inspired move.

Upamecano found impressive consistency alongside new signing Jonathan Tah. In early 2026, the now 28-year-old Frenchman earned a lucrative new contract until 2030 and a substantial signing-on fee reportedly worth €20 million. De Ligt, by contrast, suffered a back injury after a somewhat better spell in autumn 2025 and was initially sidelined.

Manchester United: Why was Matthijs de Ligt out for so long?

Ruben Amorim, United's coach at the time, called it "a minor issue", but that proved a serious misjudgement. After numerous setbacks, de Ligt returned to the training pitch only after months out, but still needed surgery in May. That ruled him out for the rest of the season and the World Cup with the Netherlands national team.

Only in late October did de Ligt make his comeback, in a 4-1 defeat to Como Calcio in the Champions League. He has made just one more brief appearance in the competition since. His last Premier League outing came on 30 November 2025, almost a year ago. Michael Carrick usually paired Harry Maguire with Lisandro Martinez in central defence. When Martinez was recently suspended, regular right-back Lenny Yoro started in the middle instead. Ayden Heaven, still only 20, also got minutes at centre-back.

Carrick lost his job during the international break and Mauricio Pochettino replaced him, extending a curious run for de Ligt. He has never started two consecutive seasons under the same coach in his entire professional career. Next season will be no different, though it remains entirely unclear which club he will play for.

His lucrative contract runs until 2029, but he has long been considered a candidate for sale. Even a winter departure is possible. "De Ligt has to go," club icon Gary Neville recently demanded. Inter Milan and Besiktas Istanbul are reportedly among the clubs considering a possible transfer for the still only 27-year-old.